Hate Crime, Statistics and Apathy

Hate CrimeWritten by Patrick Yaeger
Published in The Letter
August 2005 Issue

In the Fall of 1987, Chuck Rosenfield and his boyfriend, both in their twenties, bought and moved into what they considered their share of the American dream. Theirs was a cape cod style four bedroom on a street sandwiched between, what was then, the separate cities of Shivley and Louisville in Jefferson County, Kentucky. They were thrilled with their new home together and began readying it for visiting friends and family.

But when school let out for the Summer in 1988, a neighborhood gang of juveniles began trespassing through their property, sometimes looking in the windows. When the couple spoke up and asked the youth to stop, the intrusions only grew worse. Fences locked were climbed and damaged, a rock was thrown through the front window, and one youth even mentioned using a Molotov cocktail to ‘burn them out’. Chuck and his partner began keeping a shotgun near the bed at night.

When the Jefferson County Police were called regarding the vandalism, the officer who responded didn’t seem sympathetic. “Well, you are two men living in a house together…,” Chuck recalls him saying. There was no investigation. They sold their dream home in the Spring of 1989.

2000 Hate Crime Statistics, Uniform Crime Reporting Program, FBI
state population agencies
reporting
crime
agencies
reporting
hate
crime
overall
hate
crime
overall
lgbt
hate
crime
Kentucky 3,351,405 317 38 73 9
Indiana 4,415,055 166 31 106 15
Ohio 7,469,352 348 49 240 37
Missouri 3,843,304 186 26 70 3
Tennessee 5,685,152 422 72 230 34
Massachusetts 6,282,763 341 97 458 93
California 33,869,172 722 259 1,943 405

If it had been the year 1992, Chuck’s call might have brought a somewhat different response from the police, for in that year Kentucky passed its first piece of hate crime (also called bias crime) legislation. The statute, KRS 15.331, mandated that officers be trained to recognize hate crime. At the very least, officers in 1992 Kentucky might have been more aware that crime, when motivated by bias against homosexuals, was no less serious.

Hate Crimes: Causes, Controls, and Controversies

The first federal hate crime statute, the Hate Crime Statistics Act of 1990, mandated the collection and reporting of hate crime data. Logically, Kentucky’s 1992 statute (KRS 15.331), in addition to mandating hate crime training for officers, required the collection and reporting of hate crime to the various state and national crime databases. Therefore, in 1992, it was intended that officers, unlike the one who responded to Chuck Rosenfield’s call back in 1988, would be more capable and more likely to recognize and report hate crime.

In fact, hate crime legislation has arisen due to the growing consensus that the apathy shown by Chuck’s responding officer back in 1988 should no longer be acceptable and that crimes motivated solely by a victim’s perceived race, religion, disability, sexual orientation, or ethnicity/national origin are fundamentally more egregious than conventional crimes. These types of bias crime, it is thought, target entire communities of citizens (i.e. black, jewish, gay) and not just the individual victimized.

Though in 1992, KRS 15.331 added no penalty enhancements to this new quality of crime, it nonetheless marked a growing understanding, at the state level, of their seriousness and need for further study.

Continue reading

Share
Posted in Commentary | Leave a comment

Paragraph 175: The Holocaust and Homosexuals

Gay Holocaust VictimsGermany’s Third Reich considered homosexuals common criminals; many were arrested and sent to concentration camps. Once there, they were forced to wear a pink triangle as a brand of their supposedly ‘special’ perversion. Given the fear many gay people lived under back then, it is little wonder how little of their experiences in the death camps is known. However, it is thought that their death rate was higher than any other group.

“97 year-old Rudolf Brazda is probably the last surviving man to have been deported by the Nazis for being a homosexual. In a video interview.. he remembers his years as a prisoner at the Buchenwald concentration camp.” via Pink Triangles: The Last Known Survivor Tells His Story

Men With the Pink Triangle: The True, Life-And-Death Story of Homosexuals in the Nazi Death Camps

The following is excerpted from Daily Kos: Gays in the Holocaust: Examining the persecution of gays in the Holocaust is not “rewriting history”. It is discovering it. And those who attempt to revise or ignore this history may want to do some soul searching and be brutally honest with themselves why the fact that the Nazis – the undisputed “evil doers” of all time – oppressed gays using the same rationale that is being used today to deny basic civil rights and the opportunity to marry to homosexuals.

What were these justifications for the imprisonment, forced castration and murder of gays in Nazi Germany? It seems to have been a combination of fear of homosexuality – specifically among men – as being a cancer to the nation, that left unfettered would expand and eventually decay the body politic from within, literally like a cancer. This fear of homosexuality was combined by the Nazi desire to increase Aryan birthrate, and they viewed gay men as specifically standing in the way of this goal.

The following is excerpted from the Houston Voice about a traveling memorial to the homosexual holocaust victims: They were only numerals, three of them, but the very mention of 175 could instill fear in the hearts of gays living in Nazi Germany.

Paragraph 175 of the German Criminal Code was all the authorities needed to detain homosexuals, throw them in prison, send them to concentration camps, conduct medical experiments on them and even kill them.

Gay Victim of the Holocaust[Auschwitz mug shot of homosexual August Pfeiffer, a servant. who was born August 8, 1895, in Weferlingen, Germany. He arrived at Auschwitz on November 1, 1941, and died there December 28, 1941.]

“When the Nazis came to power, they closed the gay bars,” he (survivor Harry Pauly) recalled. “Some homosexuals, especially those who were Jewish, were killed by Nazi hooligans; my friend ‘Susi,’ a drag queen, was stabbed to death.”

Schermann, a 24-year-old Jewish shop girl living in Frankfurt, was arrested in 1940 and deported to the Ravensbrueck concentration camp for women.

Paragraph 175

Written on the back of her prisoner identification are these words: “Jenny (sic) Sara Schermann, born February 19, 1912, Frankfurt am Main. Unmarried shopgirl in Frankfurt am Main. Licentious lesbian, only visited such [lesbian] bars. Avoided the name ‘Sara.’ Stateless Jew.”

She was gassed at Bernberg in 1942.

When the concentration camps were liberated at the end of World War II, Keel (museum director) said, there was no liberation for homosexuals. Paragraph 175 remained in force.

“At the liberation in 1945, the homosexuals remained in prison to serve out their terms,” Keel said. “They weren’t given any reparations for what they had been through.”

It wasn’t until 1995, 40 years after the war’s end, that homosexuals murdered by the Nazis were recognized.

“On the 40th anniversary, a monument was set up in Germany for homosexual victims of the Holocaust,” Keel said. “In 2002, the German parliament pardoned all homosexuals.”

With a hint of sarcasm in his voice, Keel added, “It only took 60 years.”

“Homosexuals have long been targets of systematic hatred and discrimination. These images and the stories they tell document a horrible time in the history of mankind and remind us that prejudice still exists in both subtle and overt ways even today,” said Coy Tow, executive director of the Greater Houston GLBT Chamber of Commerce.

Also see: A Teacher’s Guide to the Holocaust-Homosexuals; Homosexuals, Genocide of in the Holocaust; Homosexuals, Victims of the Nazi Era; The Pink Triangle: The Nazi War Against Homosexuals; Men With the Pink Triangle: The True, Life-And-Death Story of Homosexuals in the Nazi Death Camps.

Camp VictimsSixty years ago, in the spring of 1945, Allied forces liberating Europe found evidence of atrocities which have tortured the world’s conscience ever since. As the troops entered the German concentration camps, they made a systematic film record of what they saw. Work began in the summer of 1945 on the documentary, but the film was left unfinished. FRONTLINE found it stored in a vault of London’s Imperial War Museum and, in 1985, broadcast it for the first time using the title the Imperial War Museum gave it, “Memory of the Camps.”

Watch the Full Program Online

Share
Posted in Queer Visions | Tagged death, hate crimes | 17 Comments

If by Rudyard Kipling

Rudyard KiplingIf you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too:
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or, being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or being hated don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise;

If you can dream – and not make dreams your master;
If you can think – and not make thought your aim,
If you can meet with Tiumph and Disaster
And treat those two impostors just the same:
If you can bear to hear the truth you’ve spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to, broken,
And stoop and build ‘em up with worn-out tools;

If you can make one heap of all your winnings
And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss,
And lose, and start again at your beginnings,
And never breathe a word about your loss:

If you can force your heart and nerve and sinew
To serve your turn long after they are gone,
And so hold on when there is nothing in you
Except the Will which ways to them: “Hold on!”

If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with Kings – nor lose the common touch,
If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you,
If all men count with you, but none too much:
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds’ worth of distance run,
Yours is the Earth and everything that’s in it,
And – which is more – you’ll be a Man, my son!

[I would update the last three words to "Human, dear one".]

Share
Posted in Quotes to Note | Comments Off

Dogma, Ritual, Fantasy, Idealization

KrishnamurtiKrishnamurti says that all it takes is an instant “seeing” of the things as they are. Not thinking or idealizing or pursuing or progressing towards other things or ideals but just “seeing” things as they are in this very moment. This is opposite to the psychological evolution that most operate under. Psychological evolution is the problem he says.

There is no psychological evolution. One is what one is or one is something else not based on reality but rather based on fantasies and visions in our mind. To see through this doesn’t take an immense amount of time and effort, it simply takes the understanding to do it. Once one has this understanding then all that’s left is to stop the diversionary thought worlds and efforts at “self-improvement” and simply be the real you that has always been.

Be what you are here and now, yesterday and tomorrow. Don’t try to figure out what that is for then you just end up creating another ideal or fantasy image in your mind, rather stop all that and settle into the presence all around and within you right now.

Also, he says there’s no methodology or “way” of achieving this for that in itself is another form of dogma, ritual, fantasy path that only leads away from what is already here. He understands the existence of conditioning and the barriers that this conditioning can present to those who would like to circumvent it. Again, he simply says to “see” this conditioning and then it is no longer a problem it simply is a part of what is.

It is not something to “get rid of” or work at “undoing”, rather it is a part of the reality of what is and therefore is to be “seen”, recognized, acknowledged, yet not scorned or cursed. It is real and therefore can only be seen or ignored and to ignore something that is real and a part of you is to deal in fantasy and idealization.

Share
Posted in Commentary | Leave a comment